Book review – My Plain Jane by Cynthia Hand, Jodi Meadows, and Brodi Ashton

Caidyn's review (1)

View this post on Instagram

Caidyn: Today is a very special day for me. That being, it's the third anniversary of the day I changed my name. Why is that such a big deal? Because I'm trans and that means I no longer had to go by my dead name. That day was so special and I'm so grateful that I had the ability to do it. Not all transpeople have those resources. . So, in honor of this day, I'm reading some of my highest anticipated reads! One, obviously is My Plain Jane. I had my first every @owlcrate box and I am so glad I own this book! I loved My Lady Jane so I'm excited. . I'm also going to read The Lady's Guide to Petticoats and Piracy by @themackenzilee and Bedfellow by @jeremycshipp ! . #bookstagrammer #transman #transvisibility #myplainjane #bedfellow #theladysguidetopetticoatandpiracy

A post shared by Caidyn and Chantel (@bwreviewsblog) on

4/5

TW: sexism

Continue reading

The Plague by Kevin Chong… kind of

The Plague

(Caidyn)

2/5

Thanks to Edelweiss for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. This did not affect my rating.

This book is a retelling of The Plague by Albert Camus. Which I own and read. Apparently, there’s even a review of it on Goodreads that I wrote. I gave the original book 3.5/5 but I literally don’t remember it. I don’t remember reading it. I don’t remember what happened. I don’t remember the characters. So, obviously, either my dodgy memory strikes again OR the book wasn’t that good.

But, I wanted to read this book because, hey, it sounded cool. Sadly, it came across as a huge character study rather than a book with a plot.

It follows three main characters who get trapped in Vancouver’s quarantine. Dr Bernard Rieux, a man whose wife has cancer then leaves to get treatment and his Chinese mother comes to stay and help him. Megan Tso, an author in Vancouver for her book and is trying to hide from someone. Raymond Siddhu, a journalist who is struggling after having twins and gets trapped in the city.

Major props to Chong for having all three of the main characters non-white in this retelling. I really liked that since it made me picture different people in my head while I was reading rather than some run of the mill white person.

Not only that, but all of the characters are very compelling. I could pick up the book (aka my phone) and read for a while, not even realizing how much I had read or how long I had been reading. While there isn’t a huge plot to the book, it goes fast and you get sucked in because you genuinely like all of the characters.

But, Caidyn, you ask? Why the two stars? You just told me the characters are diverse and compelling!

Well, reader, because I found it boring. Yes, I could read a whole lot and get sucked into it, but I didn’t want to pick it back up. It would take me days to weeks to decide that I wanted to pick it back up, then when I did I’d read for a long time without realizing it.

Then, even worse, I’d promptly forget everything because I sometimes skimmed over parts because, sorry, but I get bored of character development when there’s no plot. I might love the characters. I might gush about them. Yet if there’s no plot, I lose interest. Ask Chantel about our experience with Sense8. Wait don’t because you’ll make her cry.

So, all in all, I’d only recommend this book who loved the original and finds straight character studies fascinating/compelling to read. It’s a good book, but just wasn’t my type.